How Did Beethoven Become Deaf?
There are various theories circulating today regarding Beethoven’s health and hearing loss. It has been suggested that Beethoven was suffering from Syphilis (now discredited) or that he was poisoned. I have listed the presently accepted causes of his ailments and death, though tests are being carried out on his hair and should prove the matter conclusively.
Further test results on the Guavera lock of Beethoven’s hair have been published – I quote ‘The second test was a trace metals analysis conducted by Dr. William Walsh at the HRI & Pfeiffer Research Center in Naperville, Illinois. This test will reveal the presence of any trace heavy metals. The following results of this test were announced by Dr. Walsh on Tuesday, October 17th 2000:
High lead concentrations in Beethoven’s hair were found in independent analyses by McCrone Research Institute & Argonne National Laboratory. This is evidence that Beethoven had plumbism (lead poisoning) which may have caused his life-long illnesses, impacted his personality, and possibly contributed to his death. Distinctive trace-metal patterns associated with genius, irritability, glucose disorders, and malabsorption were not present in the Beethoven samples tested by McCrone Research Institute. Very low (undetectable) mercury levels were reported independently by McCrone Research Institute and Argonne National Laboratory. These results provide no evidence that Beethoven received medical treatment for syphilis, usually treated in the 1820’s with mercury compounds. This supports the consensus of Beethoven scholars who believe that Beethoven never had syphilis. Rumors that Beethoven suffered from syphilis have been discounted in all serious musicological literature for the last thirty years.’
For those seeking further information, check out the new book, ‘Beethoven’s hair’ by Russell Martin (New York, Broadway Book 2000)
DEAFNESS
The cause of Beethoven’s deafness is generally thought to have been Otosclerosis – the abnormal growth of bone of the inner ear. This bone prevents structures within the ear from working properly and causes hearing loss. Otosclerosis is a disease, which results in new bone formation either in the area of the stapes bone or in the cochlea housing the hearing nerve; or it can be a combination of both. When the bony deposits infiltrate the stapes bone, this bone is unable to vibrate and pass the sound into the inner ear. This results in what is called a conductive hearing loss, i.e., the sound is not being properly “conducted” into the inner ear. As a general rule, the thicker the bony deposit the greater the hearing loss, and the longer the hearing loss, the greater is the amount of deposits. The fixation of the stapes usually follows a slow and relentless course with progressively worsening hearing.
1796/8: First signs of deafness
1801: Complains of buzzing in ears in letter to Wegeler; Amenda
1802: “Heiligenstadt testament” – Beethoven writes of his despair at worsening hearing
1814: Further deterioration sets in. Last public appearence as pianist
1816-18: Use of ear trumpets
1818-27: Conversation books. (Conversation had to be written)
1823: Almost totally deaf (left ear not as bad as right) (MAJOR) ILLNESS -(minor intestinal problems throughout life)
1804: (spring) Serious illness, slow convalescence
1813: Serious intestinal
1824-5: Intestinal. Recovery in July
1826-7: Final Illness; Chirohsis/dropsy. (5 operations to drain fluid)
Ear Trumpets and spectacles belonging to Beethoven. Beethoven-Haus, Bonn
It’s very interesting! Some facts I learned from the book I read and I encouraged my kids to watch the movie about Beethoven’s life. We got it from Denver Library…it is very close to a very true story. The movie is really good! I wish I could remember the title of that movie.
Ok, I am trying to be nice.
Does it hurt when he puts the large horn in his ear? Is it heavy to carry around?
Hehe…why don’t you hang a coffee cup on your ear and find out. Then report the results back to us. 🙂
Interesting.
Very interesting post. I have Otosclerosis, can I now compare myself to Beethoven? 😛
i heard about beethoven i pity him… I play the piano myself and i just played his symphony !!!! i love beethoven’s tunes!!!!! i just wish he could hear his music!!!!!
i heard about beethoven i pity him… I play the piano myself and i just played his symphony !!!! i love beethoven’s tunes!!!!! i just wish he could hear his music!!!!!
way cool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Didn’t Beethoven go deaf because his father beat him almost every night?
ok i did not know beethoven was deaf thats crazy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
my name is really cacalacaloo and i love it everyone makesb fun of me and its fun because i tell them off i am soo coolllllll and you dont even know because my name is cacalacaloo!!!!hhahahahahahbahzsdlgjkl;dznxdfhkljzxcklvjXKLfhjsfhjkljfl i poop on myself
i like it
I love beethoven he is a great person 2 look up 2. Hes 1 of my idols hes great. In music class we r learning abaut him. Another thing is that his music is wonderful.If i was everybody eals i would have him as 1 of my idols like right now.If BEETHOVEN was alive right no i would say u go BEETHOVEN you rock out the hole wide world.1ns agian i love you BEETHOVEN!
Beethoven is an inspiration to the deaf and hard-of-hearing community and the world in general showing people that you can create beauty in the midst of terrible obstacles. He shows us the triumph of the human mind over matter!
I personialy dont think your theory is true
I thougt that his father used to
abuse him as a child thats why he went
deaf,but i still love beethoven wiht
all my heart,and if that did happen to him
i am truly sorry to hear that. As my mother often
tells me what god has for you can no man take it away.
I agree with what omgawolf747 says cause thats
memphis theory of beethovens codition,but if that is true
about him i am sorry to hear that cause no human
should be treated that way.
thank you for telling me how he became deaf. that was so interesting to e and my friend…
but there are a lot more Quetion for me… thank you thow
wow intresting story of him… nice one
I find this debate a very tricky one. I am an elementary music teacher, and many of my resources claim the cause of his Otosclerosis was the abuse of his father. I find it very difficult to bring this up in class, as I do not want o bring the discussion of abuse into my music class about the Ode to Joy. Is there any truth to the abuse theory? Is this just speculation? It is common knowledge that Beethoven was abused, but could this have caused the otosclerosis?
Even though Beethoven’s deafness contributed to his suffering, he wrote the most amazingly joyful music (e.g. – the Ninth Symphony). DId he fake it? Or was his faith in God and inner joy so full he triumphed over his circumstance? We can all learn to do that.
I LOVE HIM HIS MUSIC IS SO WODERFUL IT MAKES ME CRY
u boys and gurl shut up
Woow. Jst a year ago I found out he was deaf, and I always wondered if he was always deaf his whole lifee. And reading this I had a better understanding. But as he was goen deaf how did make all thosee Beautiful tunes. Was it thee Vibrations of the keys or what?
-Miss.TellyBaby.
To hear sounds, Beethoven cut off the legs of his piano and placed the instrument on the floor. He did this to feel the vibrations in the floor when he played.
stupid but i like it
ooh yeah i love beethoven show
It’s to bad Beethoven became deaf. the 5th symphony could have been so much better.
ok so i know beethoven was deaf but i thought it was a life long deafness well like they say “every day u learn somthing new” or well somthing like that. oh ya and i really do have two first names:P
To answer some of the questions….
No one really knows if abuse had anything to do with Beethoven’s deafness. So far as I know, while Beethoven’s father was abusive and a drunk, I do not believe he ever mentions being beaten every night.
The movie Immortal Beloved had a lot of fiction in it, so if that is where the idea that Beethoven’s deafness came from being beaten all the time, while it’s possible, it’s probably not true.
How did he write music while deaf? Easy. Well, for him anyway. Beethoven understood intimately the mathematics of music, and was so familiar with each and every note, he could hear what he was writing in his head.
It’s possible he could rely somewhat on the vibrations when leaning his head against the piano, but remember that Beethoven was a master of music, and his familiarity with it was all he really needed in order to write.
Beethoven wasn’t like most of us. He didn’t spend 2 or 3 hours studying music and then go do something else.
He spent hours and hours and hours every day with music. He played the piano excessively. His house maids and friends reported that Beethoven would become so caught up in the piano, that he would often skip several meals at a time. His eating habits where terrible, which probably contributed to his health problems.
He was OBSESSED with music, and could be difficult to get along with sometimes because of it.
Hope that was helpful.
I love Beethoven! What a musical genius!
I heard somewhere, that because of Beethovens deafness, he went through a manic depressive stage, and it is shown through his music. His music is like his up and down mood swings. If you notice in his songs how much emotion there is. I heard that he was very sullen over the thought of his hearing almost being completely gone. Unfortunately, his thought became reality. (Again, thats just something Ive heard.)
Hi Beethoven is one of the best compers I have ever herd.
I wish I had a time mashen and could go back in time and watch him play. He has been my all time Farit compers
BEETHOVEN IS ONE OF THE BEST COMPOSERS I HAD EVER HEARD BECUZ IT WAS SAD WHAT HAPPEN TO HIM BECUZ HE COUNDN’T HEAR ANYONE OR LISTEN TO HIS MUSIC.IF I WAS IN HIS PERSONALITITY IT WOULD HAVE BEEN DIFFICULT FOR ME.ALSO,BEETHOVEN WOULD BE IN HIS PIANO 24/7 AND WHEN i FIRST HEARD HIM IT MADE ME WANT TO CRY BECUZ OF THE DEAFNESS THAT HE HAD MUST HAD BEEN DIFFICULT FOR HIM BUT WHAT I HAD HEARD WAS THAT BECUZ OF HIS STUPID DAD BEING DRUNK HE WOULD HIT BEEHOVEN EVERYDAY BUT THATS NOT TRUE BECAUSE HE STARTED TO LOSE HIS HEARING IN HIS RIGHT EAR AND THE LEFT EAR WAS NOT SO BAD.tHEN, WHEN I HEARD MOONLIGHT SONATA IT WAS SAD TO SEE HIM DEAF AND NOT BEEN ABLE TO HEAR BECUZ THAT WAS THE BEST SONG THAT HE MADE BECUZ WHEN I SHOWED IT TO MY FRIENDS THEY WANTED TO CRY BECUZ WHAT I TOLD THEM.
THANKS BEETHOVEN FOR EVERYTHING YOU DID AND THAT U REST IN PEACE WITH NO ONE TO BOTHER OR TELL U STUFF BYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
I agree:(
beethovens music is amaziinggg!!!!!
Anhhhhhh I adore beethoven I wich I was him exept the deaf part 🙂
Well,I think Beethoven has a sign of true deternimation and a good role model to us
i hate this ???? web
shit
I knew he was deaf and that’s amazing how he can write and play music and make it sound good
cool guy
ihad a project
This is really helpful thanks!!
Thanx! This wuz abig help 4 my ASL class. But du u dink it may be the abuse as a chld dat cuzed abdomnial panes?
Wow that was strange. I just wrote an extremely long
comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all
that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say wonderful blog!
What’s up to all, the contents existing at this website are actually awesome for people knowledge, well, keep up the nice work fellows.
If some one wishes expert view concerning blogging then i
suggest him/her to go to see this weblog, Keep up the nice
work.
I know he was deaf because I am learning it in school right now
That is cool
I am so sorry that he was deaf